Carriage Inn

It seems important to preface this review by explaining that I am a pizza fanatic. I live in upstate New York now, and I think about the Carriage Inn almost every day. Everybody always says that New York is the best place for pizza. I say the Carriage Inn is the best place for pizza. The pizza is simply delicious. The crust is a medium thickness. The sauce is fantastic, spicy with a bit of sweetness. The toppings and cheese are always extremely tasty and plentiful. I don't recommend reheating it, but it's so scrumptious there probably won't be any leftovers anyway. I think all of the items on the menu are tasty, but my favorite non pizza item has to be the hot pepper cheese cubes. They are perfect. I recommend traveling across the country to get this pizza. I am counting down the days (only 55 to go) until I can travel back to Indiana to eat this pizza and visit my family. In that order. more

Carriage Inn is an old style pizza joint, which has good pizza, and outstanding cheese balls. This restaurant has a very old, classic feel to it. The prices are low, especially the beer price and the fried cheese balls are some of the best I’ve ever had. The pizzas are also good and there are plenty of pizza styles to choose from. more