This place has been around forever! Lots of locals hanging and chatting about island gossip. While their pastries aren't as to-die-for as blackbird's, the coffee is smooth and delicious and the lunch specials always satisfy. Make sure you know your barista, though, because some of them don't know ANYTHING about the proper latte pour.
Pros: Atmosphere, Local Crowds, Coffee
Cons: Service, Pastries
more