aunt polly's is the absolute best on many levels. i crave their food...crave it..... have never been disappointed....ordered from them 3 times this week. the food is always A+. i never write reviews but this place is unlike no other. i accidently was persuaded to ordered one of their desserts the other night-the pumpkin cream pie. OMG. it is incredible.i had to fight from ordering it tonight. their wings are like no other in town. you just have to trust me on this one and try them for yourself. i never even liked wings before and i ordered them a couple of months ago for a friend that was here and jesus.......they rock.. I AM HOOKED! the delivery team at aunt polly's is the best there is. i always ordered from Papa Johns before and you need to recruit RYAN from Papa John's at 10th and shadeland. he is by far the best delivery guy there is but your food beats Papa's 10 fold. the only complaint with aunt polly's is the people that take the order. this is at least the 3rd time they got my debit card wrong. because the delivery ppl. know me they continue to deliver to me even thought the phone people have my debit card wrong. i have told them over and over my card # and here the A+ delevery team still come and have to call the phone person and they have my number wrong.Your food rocks-your delivery team rocks!! we just need to get your phone people to the top. they are the only one's that suck...you guys are awesome..the food is unbelivable...your phone team just sucks...food is 110%-delivery team 110%....phone people -110%. the phone people suck...aunt polly's is one if indy's best kept secrets! i tell everyone i know!!! thanks for such great food and a terrifice delivery team. i have never had a late order...get on the ball with the phone people....best, jeff horton
Pros: the food, the delivery team
Cons: the phone staff
more