I stayed at this little Inn last weekend without having ever been to Key West or receiving any recommendations on where to stay. The proprietors were so incredibly hospitable; when they knew I would be arriving late, they left an envelope for me with keys and directions to my room. When we opened our room, we were like kids in a candy store. The rooms are huge, beautifully appointed, with great furniture, great bathrooms, ample windows...you feel like you're home. The location is great - it's on the quiet end of Duval but close enough so that you can walk everywhere (or bike). The daily breakfast out in the yard is great - there is a gorgeous old tree, a delicious hammock, and a sweet cat named Jake to keep you company. I would definitely stay there again.
Pros: Huge rooms, Great service, Great location
Cons: No pool
more