Agatina's Restaurant

Claim
marker

2967 Buffalo Road
Rochester, NY 14624

marker
1 (585) 426-0510
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Managed by Uberall
Photos
Agatina's Restaurant - Rochester, NY
Reviews
( 5 )
( 2 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )

Best

Great menu, food prepared perfectly, and wonderfully served, without a doubt is the finest restaurant in the county.

Worst

Have stopped by 3 times, but can't get a seat ;^(\r \r I suppose I should get a reservation, but they don't take them on Friday.\r \r Even tho I haven't eaten at this reputed ...

Editorial review from Citysearch 7/7/2016

The food and service\r were at a\r distinguished level.A\r big thanks to\r Agatina's staff and\r we will be back!!! more

Best in Town 3/29/2016

Great menu, food prepared perfectly, and wonderfully served, without a doubt is the finest restaurant in the county. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 2/29/2016

Best Italian restaurant in the Rochester area! more

Best in town 12/30/2015

The staff was very friendly. The food was great came over very hot. I highly recommend Agatina's Restaurant. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/30/2015

Great food. Friendly and professional staff. I highly recommend checking out Agatina's Restaurant. more

Best food in town 10/27/2015

Great staff and even better food. Our food came out very fast and was absolutely delicious. more

Great place to eat. 8/12/2015

Casual atmosphere. Great food, friendly people. I would highly recommend! more

Editorial review from Citysearch 8/11/2015

Love it! Never had a bad meal there. Many choices to choose from. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 7/6/2015

Great food at fair prices and large portion sizes. more

Delicious 3/31/2015

I love this place! It's consistently good. I love their food and the service is good. Good portion sizes. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 3/3/2015

This is one of my favorite places to eat in the Rochester area. The food is excellent and the service is top notch. more

Editorial review from Citysearch 11/28/2014

Went to Agitina’s 11/22/14 with a group of seven others. Reservations were for 7PM, didn’t get seated until after 8PM. The hostess staff appeared to care less of our delayed seating. When seated the waiter took several minutes before he approached our table and the first thing out of his mouth was that they only had two pork chops left, he then did take our drink order. When he returned with our drinks, we were ready to order but first another announcement from our waiter that the restaurant was now out of one variety of their two soup selection. When he returned with our soup he announced yet again that they were now out of eggplant. We all wondered if they would have been out of these three items if we would have been seated at or near 7PM… It was at this time that we needed to ask our waiter for bread for the table. We ordered our meals… Forty-five minutes without our waiter ever coming back once to our table to check on us, our meals were served; it was now roughly 9:15PM. To sum things up, every one of us felt the food was far below par and the drinks way overpriced. Those who had the veal said it was overdone and tough, the steak lacked taste and was also tough, the red sauce which most of us had was bitter and the linguini, clams and calamari which I had was simply terrible. All eight of us shared the same comment that we will never go to Agitina’s again! more

Can't get in, too crowded 7/26/2009

Have stopped by 3 times, but can't get a seat ;^(\r \r I suppose I should get a reservation, but they don't take them on Friday.\r \r Even tho I haven't eaten at this reputed ristorante, this website requires at least one star and one hundred fifty characters of pad my sparse, but applicable comments. more

Great Italian Food 10/17/2008

Agatina's is a popular Italian restaurant, and for good reason. They make their own pasta, sauces, and salad dressings! The portions are large, so you get your money's worth. I love the Shrimp Fra Diavola. Agatina's can also handle large groups with ease. My boss recently took 40 employees (including myself) to Agatina's for dinner, and we had seamless service; it was like there were only 5 of us! The food was fresh and made to order, and no one complained about their food! more

Agatinas 11/19/2005

This restaurant has been around for several years. It has some wonderful Italian cuisine. They do cater to larger parties, and have always treated me and my family with the utmost care. The prices are very reasonable as is the atmosphere of the restaurant. I highly recommend the Chicken parmesan. more
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for Agatina's Restaurant


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Owner Message
  • Immerse yourself in the authentic flavors of Italy right in Rochester, NY, at Agatina's. For over 35 years, our family's culinary heritage has blessed the community with rich, freshly-made Italian-American dishes. Whether it's the allure of our savory seafood, the comforting embrace of our eggplant parmesan, or the sweet temptation of handmade cannolis, Agatina's promises a symphony for every palate. Delight in our extensive GF offerings or elevate events with our off-site catering. We proudly wear our legacy on our sleeve, crafting every dish with love and tradition. Nestled in the warmth of our cozy ambiance, experience dining that transcends a meal to become a cherished memory. Dive into Agatina's-where every bite is a journey to Italy.

Additional information
  • Hours: monday: 04:00PM-08:00PM, tuesday: 04:00PM-08:00PM, wednesday: 04:00PM-08:00PM, thursday: 04:00PM-08:00PM, friday: 04:00PM-08:30PM, saturday: 04:00PM-08:30PM
badge