A Slice Of New York

Claim
marker

2407 Nicollet Ave
Minneapolis, MN 55404

marker
(612) 871-4334
Incorrect info? Correct your listing
Photos
A Slice Of New York - Minneapolis, MN
Reviews
( 7 )
( 0 )
( 0 )
( 1 )
( 0 )

Best

Lived in NYC for a few years. Left a concert tonight in a definite mood for a New York slice. Have had mediocre pizza up til now, remembered this place and thought we'd give it a ...

Worst

PLEASE do not believe the other reviews. I did and wasted money and stomach on this TERRIBLE pizza. The guy behind the counter was super nice but the food, oh the food... Just ...

No way! 7/23/2011

Lived in NYC for a few years. Left a concert tonight in a definite mood for a New York slice. Have had mediocre pizza up til now, remembered this place and thought we'd give it a try. Delicious! Very surprised to find something so close to the slices of the Big Apple! :) Will return. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Gimme a slice....please. 11/9/2010

A Slice of New York rocks! I agree with a all the positive reviews. Born and raised in New York City Queens, the slices bring me back to my roots. more
Reply | Report abuse |

Great Pizza 2/1/2010

The pizza here is the best pizza in the Minneapolis area. The dough and sauce are so good and yummy and the people there are always really nice and friendly. Though it seems like not many people do, it's a nice place to sit and eat if you're looking for some place casual. The prices are also reasonable. I would definitely recommend it. Pros: good quality and service more
Reply | Report abuse |

Finally!!! 1/11/2009

A place that gets it right!! As a native NYer from the Bronx, this place takes me back to the pizza I grew up with. The crust and sauce are what matter most and these guys nail it, even my mutha likes it! The sauce has just enough garlic but not overly-acidic and the crust isn't that doughy mess that's usually found in other pizzas around the area. The owner and the guys behind the counter are great, if you get to know them they'll try the 'experimental' new stuff on you. If you're from NY(and there seems to be a bunch of us) check this place out! Pros: Great pizza, staff are nice people Cons: Parking more
Reply | Report abuse |

Best Pizza on Eat Street! 4/11/2008

The tastiest, best proportioned pizza in south Minneapolis. Dough can be a bit fresh in the mornings, try post midnight for superbly crunchy slices. Simple cheese is amazing! Service for sit in is on the spot. If getting lasagna delivered expect 45+ min. wait, but it's well worth it. Pros: Open Late, PIZZA, Italians on the Walls Cons: Parking, Pasta Wait more
Reply | Report abuse |

ABSOLUTELY NOT!! 5/17/2006

PLEASE do not believe the other reviews. I did and wasted money and stomach on this TERRIBLE pizza. The guy behind the counter was super nice but the food, oh the food... Just say no! Pros: friendly service Cons: food, parking more
Reply | Report abuse |

best in town!!! 7/14/2003

The previous user said it so well I can't add much. There's nothing worse than ""gentrified"" pizza. This is classic NY pizza at it's best. Pros: best in town, thin crust, N.Y. Style Cons: not a one more
Reply | Report abuse |

back off; only real new yorkers apply! 10/4/2002

This place has been the ONLY place in Minneapolis that even tries for NYC level pizza. I grew up in Brooklyn, NY and believe me, I know 'za. You can set the standards of the pizza joint by their Sicilian slice and this place gets it right. Forget the other pizza poseurs in the neighborhood!(you know who you are) A Slice of New York's slices are perfect combination of sauce, crust and cheese. Forgeddaboudit!!! Pros: Slices, Sicilian, Italians on the wall Cons: parking more
Reply | Report abuse |
< Previous 1 Next >
Menu for A Slice Of New York


Summer SALE!!!:
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use year15 at checkout. Expires 1/1/2021
Owner Message

  • The owner of this shop on Nicollet Ave serves the best pizza in town. The crusts are hand spun. If you like a milder pizza or you're bigger on the cheese than on the sauce, A Slice of New York is for you. All of the pizza is homemade with fresh dough on a daily basis, and pies range from 10 to 20 dollars.

    Delivery is available to South Minneapolis and all of Downtown Minneapolis. Delivery is available until 3 AM.

    New York-style pizza at its best. The pizzeria also offers Stromboli and Calzone as well as a variety of pasta specials. The Calzone here are mind blowing. A Slice of New York can accommodate parties up to twenty patrons in size, and will deliver as well. If you're in the mood for great pizza, check this joint out.


    * Pizza

    * Gyros

    * Italian

    * Delivery

    * Late Night

    * Takeout/Carryout

Additional information
  • Payments: Cash, Visa, Master Card
  • Neighborhoods: Powderhorn, Whittier
badge